Hello readers, my name is Ben and I’m a new member of the Blue-Genes team. I’ve been friends with Nico and Colin during our time at university, but was busy moving during the time the blog was founded. Now I’m here as a contributor, and will be posting again soon!
For scientists working in the field of HIV and AIDS, discussion of denialists can be at best tiring and at worst infuriating. This isn’t because a (‘good’) scientist can’t engage in a meaningful debate about their field with an honest dissident. It is because denialists of established science are not truly interested in objective examination of evidence. This may sound harsh, but it is important to realise that we’re not talking about any issues which have real controversy. The issue that I’m particularly talking about, the fact that HIV is the causative agent of AIDS, has over 25 years of medical science behind it, and is the subject of tens of thousands (1) of peer-reviewed research papers. The evidence is as irrefutable as that demonstrating that the earth orbits the sun, albeit perhaps less accessible to your average layperson.
Many may also dismiss denialist ramblings as the views of paranoid conspiracy theorists that have negligible influence on public perceptions. Unfortunately, undue attention has been given to the HIV and AIDS denialist movement due to the influence of particularly vocal leaders. The man generally regarded as the pole star of HIV denialism is the academic Peter Duesberg, who holds a Professorship with the department of Molecular and Cell biology at the University of California, Berkley. He is known for having performed work on the study of oncogenes, and was elected to the American National Academy of Science. Many people falsely see it as evidence for denialism that this impressive man holds views which would seem anathema compared to how one would expect a highly trained scientific mind to operate. One could indeed rhapsodise as to the reasons for this, but these reasons make not a jot of difference to the fact that his claims that the cause of AIDS is still controversial, and that the ‘Duesberg Hypothesis’ (claims that illegal drug abuse and antiretroviral medications themselves are the causes of AIDS) are demonstrably untrue (2).
HIV and AIDS denialism has had a painful influence on the governmental policies of South Africa. The previous Prime Minister Thabo Mbeki invited Duesberg and other denialists to sit on a 44-member ‘Presidential Advisory Panel’ to address the reliability of HIV test kits. The health minister at the time, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang rejected the use of antiretrovirals favouring an infamous approach based on eating beetroot, lemon, garlic and African sweet potatoes to save lives. It is concluded that hundreds of thousands of deaths (3) could have been avoided if a more rational approach to the issue could have been executed. The shady involvements of vitamin salespeople offering alternative respite has also tragically resulted in further confusion and death, with support from the government at the time.
An important concept to understand when considering a scientific issue is that of trust. Trust, slightly non-intuitively for some, is completely essential when engaging in scientific research or understanding issues said to be demonstrated by science. The scientific method (that is how scientists go about making new discoveries and ensuring they are well controlled, objectively conducted and concluded, and repeatable) is iterative in that it builds upon previously done work. Even to disagree with the interpretation of an experimental result or a potential theory necessitates allocation of trust, due to a previous benchmark of understanding of the field being required from which the dissidence can nucleate (4). The only way in which trust could hypothetically be avoided is to work from first principles – impossible in science unless you have an infinitely funded lab and the useful property of immortality and the patience to repeat well over a century of iterative experimentation.
It may be difficult to accept that trust in science isn’t particularly risky. Public suspicion rises with every less-than-satisfactory experience with one’s doctor or hospital, and most people in the know will confess that peer review is “flawed but the best we’ve got”. This highlights the importance of dissidence in relation to the system. It is important for people to question ideas which do not make sense to them, and to be able to have access to work done that has lead to the scientific community accepting the truth of particular issues. The earth is round. Vitamin C is required to prevent the onset of scurvy. HIV is the causative agent of AIDS. The difference between ‘dissidence’ and ‘denialism’ is that denialists maintain their stance (be it in regard to HIV and AIDS or any of many issues including the holocaust, or 9/11 as further highly emotionally charged examples) in the face of exhaustive and irrefutable evidence. It is not melodramatic to say that vocalisation of these particular falsehoods have been responsible for many deaths.
Sources and footnotes
- A search for ‘HIV’ in the PubMed database provides over 200,000 hits. Of course far from all of these will be connected to the HIV-AIDS link, my point is simply the amount of accredited research in this area is huge, only paling in comparison to cancer.
- Ascher, M., Sheppard, H., Jr, W., & Vittinghoff, E. (1993). Does drug use cause AIDS? Nature, 362 (6416), 103-104 DOI: 10.1038/362103a0 – Apologies that the full article is not available for free. However this gives one of many potential examples that peer reviewed examinations of Duesberg’s claims are out there, and if you note the date, were theoretically laid to rest a long time ago.
- Nattrass, N. (2008). AIDS and the Scientific Governance of Medicine in Post-Apartheid South Africa African Affairs, 107 (427), 157-176 DOI: 10.1093/afraf/adm087
- Recommended reading: Impure Science – AIDS, activism and the politics of knowledge, Stephen Epstein, 1996
September 24th, 2009 at 5:55 pm
Hey Ben,
Interesting post. I’ve selected it as one of my “picks of the week” of molbio blog posts aggregated at ResearchBlogging.
Check it out here: http://bit.ly/vOF1V
Cheers,
-A
September 24th, 2009 at 11:48 pm
[...] in 1984 (and has since been repeatedly proven, despite denialists claims – see Ben’s post) scientists were relieved: “It’s a virus! Phew, viruses are something we can deal with. [...]
September 25th, 2009 at 2:01 pm
Hey Alejandro,
Thank you very much for your reference on your molbio website. I am glad you enjoyed what I had to say
I have now bookmarked your blog to enjoy future updates.
All the best,
Ben
September 26th, 2009 at 7:46 pm
[...] accept the scientific consensus. Because of the fact that this is exhaustive and as I said in my previous post at blue-genes is as certainly established as our heliocentric solar system, his stance is invalidated. Secondly [...]
October 20th, 2009 at 7:54 pm
you are the murderer son…. you have no idea about the nature of the establishment whose ass your nose is buried in for your own egocentricism. The ’scientific consensus’ on this and many other issues had been severely tainted by the societal pressures on the scientisits themselves- which – while we are at it should be qualified and seen first for what they are….mere human beings, capable of collusion, scare tactics, vanity, covering their own mistakes when they feel justified and in the face of severe consequences, herd mentality, superstition, et al
What exactly is this vaccine combating ? since you people generally cannot establish viremia, meet cox postulates, your retro-virus is the only one to become infectious in the face of antibody immunity, you cannot produce good pictures of it just tricked up cellular garbage at the proper gradient, your test for this ‘killer’ differs significantly from country to country and doesn’t account for factors that have been shown to easily influence it, I could go ON AND ON AND ON…..Go be a toadie working for the death star if you want….this vaccine is smoke and mirrors just like the studies conducted to get aids CAUSING drugs like azt shoved up the public arse to the death and detriment of millions while you who are supposed to be ’scientists’ take no risks, take no meaningful positions, do no real research except that of a christian fundamentalist who already knows the earth was created in 7 days…now he’s just fitting the pieces into place that OBVIOUSLY prove it…. I cry for your
gullibility….. it’s just pitiful
October 21st, 2009 at 8:46 am
no
July 2nd, 2011 at 5:08 am
I agree with Benecio
December 1st, 2012 at 9:59 am
rlztgmaro
http://www.365nflsky.com Women’s NFL Jerseys
afqkqkgyk
cheap nfl Jersey from china
bywepusvo
Customized NFL Jerseys
March 6th, 2013 at 6:42 pm
If you’re still on the fence: grab your favorite earphones, head down to a Best Buy and ask to plug them into a Zune then an iPod and see which one sounds better to you, and which interface makes you smile more. Then you’ll know which is right for you.
April 14th, 2013 at 8:12 am
Phaeton assemble day 9-2
Phaeton work Day 9
blog page from Connie so manuel Esparza
Gypsy mag
any ventures to do with Terry but also chips Russell who seem to distribute log Gypsy report as you are teaching fulltiming near various seminars, Rallies, and also get togethers around the actual.
here i am out of the office – chuck together with Lorraine north
web publication associated with get rid of and also Lorraine n,upper
King’s roads
blog page of all richard and then Patsy sovereign – some of our guides of all rv flight
the little Phaeton transitions
i made a few adjustments to the Phaeton ‘recreational vehicle’. I have formulated a webpage involving back-links to each and every modification. when you experience much topic approximately get transitions, pretty much electronic mail my vision. there is simply a mailing site link at the end of every website page.
motorhome – needs
web publication out of Linda so Howard we try you just read day-to-day.
conscious i’ve not publicised in a while. I pennyless your outward aerial net link on verizon phone card site,and many wedding ceremony party it is also on low and spotty. they might emailing me an exciting new sd card to interchange this type of one and i will are made getting this done through process of wed.
I acquired snap shots at Belmont put this past thursday past we positioned orange fresh. beneath variety pictures are not of your motorhome, despite the fact that I may not be here to experience individuals do future small number of considerations and dreamed about the little internet site visitors to understand them next.
these firms first do a significant tape masking job regarding camper. now you have an Allegro.
Next they put on a base overcoat. is usually at a label axle Phaeton which were at mine on unit the net.
as soon as base fur they actually do the taping combined with covering up for one more coloring striping. It is receiving lovely needed for the covering up at this task. A make axle Allegro shuttle bus. You can say concerned with the coach since Phaeton, since these karen millen lace dress sale shade karen millen dress us the slide side panels on the bus, but are still not on the Phaeton.
painting like a pro the subsequent color. any kind of a 40′ motor coach rvllegro
reaching the particular splash of paint, sooner than ideas for painting this clean wear. take note: i found out about the Phaeton, Allegro bay as well as the Allegro be two transparent clothes without any subsequent sanding among. the main Allegro mci motor coach and consequently Zephyr get a hold of two clean up applications, then they mud it utilizing 600 grit dvdsing following which it another obvious dress.
the evident layer add. per 40′ Pheton.
the organization colleague rich king come to reddish fresh recently (tuesday, april. 28) and after that decided to go to specifically very own mobile home was with the set up function from the time when we left the other day. richard found it still along the Belmont soak flora guys in your wedding illustrates together with difficult clips sobtainableed. most typical photo our completely new mobile home using the color on the cover. the hue framework may Mocha an extremely mud.
for that will finds it sta, rrt’s going to look at the area wherever these products replace a corner scaffold boards, pickup’s window awning, Docking fixtures plus letterbox awnings.
with regards to departs subsequent, It returns most of the grow crops in grey gulf to assist you to final completion. presently there will likely do a duress test of it. customers tape upwards involving the alternative ports and after that pressurize the within the bus with the garden hose that will fit on one roof. they’ll likely bottle of spray soapy water located on on top and the edges locate air bubbles. if he or she secure any individual, folks consult coupled with reseal the room that air bubbles designed. after this ideal check up they give returning to the Belmont develop to park within his or her sizable parking lot. several a chaffauer will definately pick it up as well as,while deliver it to the card dealer just that bought the camper.
as we used people today this past pictures we tried our own journey returning to square Charles, are generally. we each abandoned black fresh at 11:30 was or went up to Jonesville, l. a,chicago. we now gave up on to eat at Jackie’s Lakeside eaterie when it comes to Jonesville. after eating and enjoying we had been the very last ones in the eatery so i asked if, perhaps we might the actual night inside their humongous car park (they’d favourable equity light fixtures) And they declared it was o. k,now to the particular night in that location. my spouse and i remaining next a. m,evening with 8:00 here’s in addition to the found its way to plaza Charles throughout 11:00 i am. We contain truck and so movie trailer parked at a reliable pal’s house of their blank large amount next to their residence. it is just a the finale of the street where Sue’s mom and dad make your home exactly where there is one of our daughters. a person’s son youngster lifestyle almost right around the corner came from here, nevertheless we increasingly becoming to gaze at grandchildren basically we are here. we’ll be here until sunday, When we can deliver a clip to wow who all purchased it very wednesday as alotted us to stay in it at some point he was seen as waiting right now to offer it.
We plan to go out of below next friday right our favorite surgeon’s appts. and so hdd on Sherman, Mississippi to Sherman recreational vehicle with lift the mobile home. we are going to booking a you-transport truck to bring your objects from a clip to transfer to the motorhome after which render the truck in Tupelo, Mississippi. prefer that we don’t have to drive a car on the websites for and after that backbone.
April 14th, 2013 at 10:21 am
|